≡ Menu

Guest Post – On Being a Misfit

Today’s guest post is written by fellow blogger Elaine Kehoe. Elaine is a freelance copyeditor and a writer whose work has appeared or will appear in the journals Rosebud, Word Riot, The Quotable, and Relief, as well as at 12Most.com. She blogs at Tea Leaves.

On Being a Misfit

I am an outcast, an outlier, different. A member of a minority group.

Yes, there are actually stores I can’t get served in.

Shoe stores.


I happen to have extremely narrow feet. If you belong to this rare group, you’ll understand what I mean.

Remember when shoe store clerks used to measure your feet when you went to buy shoes? While I was growing up and even for years afterward, I didn’t have major problems. I was able to shop in most shoe stores and even department stores. Many major shoe manufacturers (such as Naturalizer) made shoes in various narrow widths, and most stores had a selection in stock for me to choose from. The narrowest shoes I ever remember buying were a width of 4A with a 6A heel, and they fit me perfectly.

Such is no longer the case.

Over the years I began to notice the gradual disappearance of narrow-width shoes from both shoe stores and department stores. In some cases I would need to select a style I liked and the store would order it in the correct width.

Nowadays, it seems that manufacturers are no longer willing to make anything that they can’t sell a gazillion of. There’s no room in the bottom line for items that appeal to less than the majority. And even the few that are made rarely find shelf space in retail stores. They just can’t afford to keep stock that won’t sell quickly.

I am reduced to two brands that I can shop for: New Balance and Easy Spirit. I wear New Balance running shoes, and when I need a new pair, I have to go to a store that carries the brand and have them order a pair from the manufacturer, which may take a few weeks. Easy Spirit used to maintain a retail store in a mall near us. Now that store is closed, and the only one available is in an outlet mall in Massachusetts. Even when I can get there, the stock is limited; these styles can’t be ordered, and I have to scour the shelves looking for anything in 9 ½ N in a style I like and can wear, and sometimes I need to compromise on style. Failing that, I need to order online, which means I can’t try them on, which means I can’t be sure they’ll fit right or feel comfortable – which can lead to frustration and either going to the trouble (and expense) to return them or throwing them in the back of the closet and trying again to find another pair.


Naturally, I also cannot shop in Payless or other discount shoe stores; thus I need to pay more than I might want to just to have something to put on my feet.

And suppose these two brands decide it’s no longer profitable to make shoes in uncommon widths? Will I need to find a cobbler who can make them to order? Wrap my feet in rags? Have surgery to graft more flesh onto my feet?

This seems to me emblematic of a paradox: that is, a lack of choice in a society that purports to offer so many choices in everything. You can walk into a shoe store today and see ten thousand pairs of shoes in ten thousand styles and colors – all in B widths. Yet no one can make or sell even a small number of shoes in other widths. It seems that the only real choices are those that make the most money for manufacturers and retailers.

I wish that those of us who are hard to fit in any way and find their choices increasingly limited could join up in a movement. There must be a lot of us. Maybe together we could force manufacturers and retailers to listen to and consider our needs.

And yet I fear that those of us who don’t fit the norms are destined to be voices in the wilderness.

~ Elaine Kehoe, Tea Leaves

NaBloPoMo July 2014

Thank you for sharing, Elaine!

Laurel Storey, CZT – Certified Zentangle Teacher. Writer, reader, tangler, iPhoneographer, cat herder, learner of French and Italian, crocheter, needle felter, on-and-off politics junkie, 80s music trivia freak, ongoing work in progress.

{ 12 comments… add one }
  • John Holton
    July 26, 2014

    I know how you feel, Elaine: I’m a 9 1/2 4E, and it’s only because I found a shoe store online that deals with sizes that wide that I can find anything.
    John Holton recently posted… Time Management Secret: “YES Makes Less” from “Writers In The Storm” (#blogboost)My Profile

    • ElaineLK July 26, 2014

      It’s frustrating, isn’t it, John? It’s like we don’t matter at all. Does your online shoe store carry narrow widths, too, or just wide?

  • Amy Morgan July 26, 2014

    Sounds very frustrating Elaine. I must admit, I buy shoes very rarely but when I do now, I’ll be on the lookout for venues that carry narrow and let you know. Nice guest post!

    • ElaineLK July 26, 2014

      Hey, Amy, how do you get away with rarely buying shoes?? You must walk very lightly, lol. I would love to know if there are any stores that still carry narrow widths, even though I’m a little far from Grand Island. I’d just feel it a little bit of a triumph to know there were still some! Thanks for reading.

  • Tara McNamara
    July 26, 2014

    YES! What would us high-instep, wide footed folk do without New Balance?!

    • ElaineLK July 30, 2014

      Tara, I hope you and I never have to find out!

  • Carol Cassara
    July 27, 2014

    Catering to the common denominator, that’s what it is.s
    Carol Cassara recently posted… Brains and backgammonMy Profile

    • ElaineLK July 27, 2014

      It sure is, Carol. It’s bad enough in our culture, but when it comes to things people really NEED, it’s putting a lot of people in a very difficult spot.

  • ElaineLK July 27, 2014

    Laurel, again, thanks so much for allowing me to be a part of Alphabet Salad this week, and for the great photos you found!

  • Alana
    July 29, 2014

    My husband is a size 14 W – and it is hard for him to find shoes in regular stores. I can identify with this post as I see his frustration when he shoe shops. Isn’t it amazing, in a way, that we live in a world where customization was supposed to become the norm, because of computers – but instead, things have become more cookie cutter?
    Alana recently posted… How A Journey of 1000 Steps Begins – Part 1My Profile

    • ElaineLK July 30, 2014

      I agree completely, Alana. You would think that in such a varied society everyone would be able to find the right thing for his or her needs, but unfortunately that is becoming less and less true. Does your husband have to shop online?


Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: